Most organisations proudly say their people are their biggest asset, yet far too many go "shopping for strangers" when a leadership role opens up, instead of looking at the internal talent they already have. External (and internal) recruiters are briefed, and extended searches often end up costing the business in lost momentum. Sometimes the people who could step up are already sitting in the next office, quietly doing more than their job title suggests.
Why do organisations default to external hiring for leadership roles?
Recruiting from outside generally feels like the safest option because it looks like a clear decision was made. The company writes a brief, draws up a shortlist and applies its current salary banding method. It feels rigorous, and it leaves a paper trail.
Where things start to fail is when a new external hire arrives without any knowledge of how the business really works, or of the people who know it best. Worse still is finding out that some of those people had been overlooked for the role.
CVs record what someone has done. They say very little about the potential a person offers under pressure. Qualifications and previous job titles tell you where someone has been, but rarely tell you how they will behave when a client is unhappy or a key project starts to slip.
What does hidden leadership talent look like?
Hidden leaders are rarely the people who announce it. They just make things better, and as a result, colleagues start turning to them as the first point of contact.
Think about a time when you noticed leadership quietly announce itself in how someone handled tension and pressure. Maybe it's the person who calms a difficult meeting, saves an unhappy client from leaving, or resolves a critical issue in one meeting instead of four. This is where soft skills turn into hard currency.
What happens when you back internal talent?
Next time you have the chance, give that person a piece of work that matters, with a clear outcome. Back them properly and give them the authority to deliver it. The responsibility typically builds leadership capability faster than any expensive training course can, and it shows you quickly whether the instinct is real.
Set time aside to review progress together, the way a good mentor would, and tell them what you're noticing. For me, it's important to be crystal clear in your communication, while also being kind in how you give feedback. Recognition and feedback that's honest and delivered with humility is also one of the reasons people stay.
When people see that capability is recognised from within, the culture shifts. Loyalty and employee engagement grow because people can see a future for themselves. Commercial judgement improves because the people closest to the work are trusted to make decisions about it. And the business keeps the knowledge it has already paid for, instead of paying a premium to buy it in from outside.
How can you find future leaders already in your organisation?
Pick a person in your organisation who has gone above and beyond what their current role asks. Have a conversation with them, maybe over coffee or lunch. Ask them what they've noticed about the organisation through their eyes, and what they would do if they had more responsibility.
It's a small step, and it fits alongside any wider leadership development strategy you already run. You may find the next leader you need is already in the room.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why should organisations develop leaders from internal talent?
Organisations that develop leaders from internal talent keep the knowledge they've already paid for, build loyalty because people can see a future for themselves, and improve commercial judgement by trusting the people closest to the work to make decisions about it.
How do you spot hidden leadership potential in your team?
Hidden leadership potential shows up in how someone handles tension and pressure: calming a difficult meeting, saving an unhappy client from leaving, or resolving a critical issue in one meeting instead of four. Colleagues often start turning to these people first.
How do you test whether an internal candidate is ready to lead?
The quickest way to test whether an internal candidate is ready to lead is to give them a piece of work that matters, with a clear outcome and the authority to deliver it, then review progress together and give honest, kind feedback on what you notice.
💡 Interested in booking Matt Garman for your next leadership event or workshop? Send us a message via the chat and we'll scope the right format and a quote for your audience. Remember, it's always a good time to get a PepTalk!
